Table Of Contents
YES! There's a dark side to buying e-commerce businesses that sellers won’t tell you…
Before you buy that established store, pause for a moment and ask yourself:
What if it comes with hidden problems that could ruin your plans?
Buying an established e-commerce business can be an exciting opportunity, especially when you consider the time and effort it saves you.
You simply SKIP the startup phase and acquire a business that’s already making money.
But this path is not without its challenges.
What many buyers don’t realize is that there’s more to it than just paying for the site and assuming everything will run smoothly.
Below, we’ll look at 10 critical things that nobody will ever tell you about buying an established e-commerce website.
We Help You Buy / Build, Manage and Scale E-commerce Brands for an EXIT
E-commerce Simplified for Busy Individuals – We handle the buying, building, and scaling, so you can focus on what matters.
Growth-Focused Strategies – From sourcing to marketing, we drive growth and prepare you for a profitable exit.
Expertly Managed Exits – We build a high-value brand designed for a Lucrative exit.
1. The Numbers Might Not Tell the Whole Story
The financials are an essential consideration when buying any business. However, the numbers you see don’t always tell the full story.
You’ll likely be presented with profit-and-loss statements and other data showing how much the business makes.
But the context behind those numbers is equally important.
For example:
How much of the revenue is from recurring customers vs. one-time buyers?
A business with a solid repeat customer base is far more valuable than one relying heavily on new customers each month.
What are the costs that aren’t accounted for in the reported numbers?
Are there hidden expenses like high marketing costs, customer service overhead, or returns that aren’t fully accounted for in the financial documents?
When evaluating financials for an online store on sale, look for patterns in the data and ask probing questions to understand the full picture.
2. You Might Be Buying Someone Else’s Burnout
It’s easy to assume that buying an established online business means inheriting something that’s “set up for success.”
However, what you might actually be purchasing is a business that’s exhausted its owner.
Some sellers are simply burnt out and looking to cash out after years of hard work.
Burnout for the sellers can stem from many factors, including:
Marketing fatigue: Constantly trying to find new customer acquisition channels, deal with ever-changing algorithms, or keep up with seasonal shifts can be overwhelming.
Product fatigue: When an e-commerce business relies on a narrow product line or a few key products, it may be tough to stay motivated to grow or innovate, especially when sales stagnate.
Lack of automation: If the seller has been running the business manually for years, the day-to-day operations can be draining. Without proper systems in place, it becomes hard to scale.
Monotony or creativity burnout: After doing the same thing day in and day out, even passionate business owners can feel creatively drained and uninspired to drive new growth.
Before you pull the trigger, ask yourself this:
Why is the owner selling?
Is there a clear reason why the business has plateaued or is in decline?
If the business has stagnated, you must factor in the effort and resources needed to revitalize it.
Don’t just assume that the business will keep running smoothly without your intervention.
Here are additional tips to help you spot burnout in a potential purchase:
Flat or Declining Revenue: Stagnant or declining revenue suggests the owner is no longer focusing on growth. Review financials to see if the business is growing or just maintaining.
Lack of Innovation or New Product Launches: If new products, campaigns, or innovations have slowed or stopped, it may indicate the owner has stopped pushing for growth. Ask about future plans.
High Owner Dependence: If the owner is the main driver of sales through branding or direct relationships, the business may be too reliant on their personal involvement. Look for automation or outsourcing.
Seller Fatigue During Conversations: If the seller seems tired, frustrated, or disengaged when discussing the business, they may be burnt out. Passionate owners are typically excited about their business.
Inconsistent Marketing or Advertising: A decline in marketing quality or frequency suggests a lack of energy for continued promotion. Successful businesses need consistent marketing efforts.
3. Not All E-Commerce Models Are Created Equal
One of the key factors you can use in determining the value of an e-commerce business is its business model.
Just because a business seems profitable doesn’t mean it’s built on a sustainable or scalable model.
The model you’re inheriting matters a lot more than it might initially appear.
Ask yourself:
Is the business reliant on a single supplier or product?
If your main supplier goes out of business or discontinues a product, you could face significant challenges.
Is the business heavily reliant on one marketing channel?
If the business’s growth is dependent on paid ads (Google or Facebook), you’ll want to assess how vulnerable that strategy is to changes in advertising costs or platform algorithm updates.
Diversification and multiple revenue streams are signs of a more stable and scalable business.
4. The Customer Base Might Not Be Loyal
Probably one of the best things about buying an established e-commerce business is the customer base that comes with it.
However, just because a business has a large number of customers doesn’t mean they’re loyal or engaged.
So, how do you establish the legitimacy of the customer base?
Here are some KEY things to look out for:
Customer retention rates: An online store that boasts high customer acquisition costs with a low repeat purchase rate could be a red flag.
Email list quality: A large email list is only valuable if it’s engaged. Therefore, it’s advisable to check the open rates and conversion metrics to help you assess how well the list is performing.
A solid, loyal customer base is a significant asset for an online business, but it needs to be nurtured to keep its value high.
We Help You Buy / Build, Manage and Scale E-commerce Brands for an EXIT
E-commerce Simplified for Busy Individuals – We handle the buying, building, and scaling, so you can focus on what matters.
Growth-Focused Strategies – From sourcing to marketing, we drive growth and prepare you for a profitable exit.
Expertly Managed Exits – We build a high-value brand designed for a Lucrative exit.
5. The Seller Might Have Hidden or Lax Processes
If you’re buying an existing online business, chances are the seller has been running it for a while.
What you may not realize is that they might have developed shortcuts or inefficient systems that worked for them but will be a headache for you.
Don’t get it?
Let’s break it down…
Consider these common issues:
Manual processes: These might seem small, like having to enter orders manually or responding to customer service issues without a ticketing system, but they can quickly add up.
Inconsistent inventory management: If inventory isn’t tracked well, you could find yourself out of stock at the worst time or overstocked with unsellable goods.
As you can see, such a seller’s operational processes may need significant upgrading to increase the efficiency of your store operations.
To avoid falling into this trap, you should ensure you ask for detailed explanations of how day-to-day tasks are handled.
6. You’ll Likely Need To Keep the Seller Around for a While
Yes! Buying a ready-to-go online business doesn’t mean you’ll instantly become an expert.
In fact, you may need the seller’s help more than you think—especially during the transition phase.
Some sellers may offer you training or transition support, but this is not always guaranteed.
To avoid headaches post-acquisition, you’d want to negotiate the following:
Transition period: How long will the seller be available to assist you in the handover? Will they be available for follow-up support if needed?
Documentation: Ensure you get all necessary documents, including instructions on any systems, tools, and marketing strategies.
Without this support, the learning curve could be steep, and you could risk losing momentum during the transition.
7. The SEO Might Not Be as Strong as It Seems
Search Engine Optimization (SEO) is often one of the most valuable assets of an established e-commerce store.
However, you should never assume the SEO of the store you’re buying is in great shape just because it has been around for a while.
You’ll need to take some steps to analyze the store’s SEO quality. And you can do this by checking these crucial areas:
The quality of backlinks: Are they natural and high-quality? Or are they spammy links that could hurt SEO in the long run?
Organic rankings: Are the rankings sustainable? Is the store ranking well for specific keywords? Do those keywords still have a strong search volume?
If the e-commerce business relies on organic search for traffic, you’ll want to do a deep dive into the SEO strategy and audit to ensure it's sustainable.
8. The Business Might Have Reliance on Specific Platforms
Many e-commerce businesses rely on third-party platforms for marketing, fulfillment, or even the selling process itself.
This can include platforms like Amazon and eBay, or social media channels like Facebook and Instagram.
Here are some things to consider in such a case:
Platform dependency: Is the business reliant on one or two platforms for the majority of its revenue? If these platforms change their policies, algorithms, or fees, it could have a serious impact on the business.
Fulfillment dependency: Are you using third-party fulfillment or dropshipping that could suddenly become unreliable? How easy is it to switch suppliers or fulfillment partners?
Be prepared to take action if these external dependencies become issues after the acquisition.
9. The Seller’s Customer Support Might Not Be Up to Par
Customer service is one of the most critical areas of any business, and it’s easy to overlook its importance when purchasing an e-commerce site.
However, inheriting a business with poor customer service could result in frustrated customers, bad reviews, and higher churn rates.
Thankfully, this is something you can avoid by asking the seller the right questions.
You should ask:
How is customer support handled? Are there clear processes for handling returns, complaints, and product inquiries?
Are there any unresolved issues with customers? Review customer service logs and ask the seller about any common customer complaints.
A business with a poor customer service reputation can cause long-term damage to the brand.
10. The Business Needs to Be Treated Like a Startup Again
Because you’re buying an already-running e-commerce business, it’s easy to think that you can sit back and watch the money roll in. Right?
Unfortunately, that’s not quite the case.
In many ways, you’ll need to treat it like a startup—especially if you want to grow and scale the business.
You should expect to do the following after acquiring an e-commerce business:
Implement new marketing strategies: What worked for the previous owner might not work for you. Thus, we advise you to test new approaches to digital marketing, SEO, and social media.
Optimize operations: Carefully look for inefficiencies in the business and ways to automate processes.
Plan for growth: Develop a clear strategy to scale the business further, whether through new products, new customer acquisition channels, or expanding into new markets.
Overall, you’ll still need to put in the effort to ensure the business you acquire remains profitable and grows under your ownership.
Conclusion
Buying an established e-commerce business lets you inherit a revenue-generating venture and bypass the challenges of starting from scratch.
Before you make a purchase, be sure to understand the common issues that many buyers tend to overlook throughout the acquisition process. We just outlined the top 10 issues you should be aware of to help you navigate the journey with confidence.
The key to a successful purchase is thorough due diligence, asking the right questions, and preparing for a period of transition and growth.
If you still feel you need some help to confidently acquire a profitable e-commerce business, we’re here to support you. With years of industry experience, our team of experts has a sharp eye for spotting potential red flags and ensuring you avoid costly acquisition mistakes.
We’ll help you secure a business that’s positioned for growth. Post-acquisition, we give you full management and scaling to drive your business toward 2x to 10x returns—maximizing your potential when it's time to exit.
Click Here to discover how we can help you own a profitable online business today!
A Done-For-You E-commerce Business
Discover how we Build, Launch, and Scale a 6-figure/month Business for You
Learn more
