One of the first crossroads you'll face when starting a business is deciding between franchising and building your own brand.
Both paths can lead to success, but they come with different challenges and rewards.
Let's dive into real-world examples and hard data to help you make an informed decision.
The Franchise Route: A Proven Path with Its Own Challenges
Amit Kleinberger's journey with Menchie's Frozen Yogurt is a testament to the potential of franchising.
Starting with a single store in 2007, Kleinberger grew Menchie's into a global brand with over 540 locations across 14 countries by 2019.
The key to his success?
A strong focus on customer experience and a flexible franchise model that allowed for local customization.
"We're not in the frozen yogurt business," Kleinberger often says. "We're in the business of making people smile."
This philosophy, combined with a proven business model, helped Menchie's achieve an impressive average unit volume of $466,000 per store in 2019.
The Numbers Behind Franchising
According to the International Franchise Association (IFA):
1. The $670 billion contribution to the U.S. economy in 2020 indicates that franchising is a significant and robust sector. This suggests potential stability and growth opportunities for franchise owners, which could be appealing for those looking to invest in a proven business model.
2. With approximately 773,603 franchise establishments in the United States, there's a wide variety of options available across different industries. This large number also implies that franchising is a popular and potentially successful business model. However, it also means increased competition, so potential franchisees should carefully consider their chosen market and location.
3. The average initial investment range of $50,000 to $200,000 helps set realistic expectations for potential franchisees. This information is crucial for financial planning and determining if franchising aligns with one's budget and risk tolerance. It's important to note that costs can vary significantly depending on the industry and brand, so thorough research into specific franchise opportunities is essential.
However, it's not all smooth sailing. A study by FranchiseGrade.com found that 19.3% of franchises fail within the first five years.
While this is lower than the failure rate for independent businesses, it's still a significant risk.
Building Your Own Brand: A Viable Road Less Traveled
Sara Blakely's journey with Spanx is a prime example of the potential of building your own brand.
Starting with just $5,000 and a brilliant idea for footless pantyhose, Blakely built Spanx into a billion-dollar company.
In her own words: "I started Spanx with $5,000 in savings, and I've never taken outside investment. I want women to know it's possible to start a business with little money and grow it slowly."
By 2012, Blakely became the youngest self-made female billionaire at age 41.
Spanx's success stems from Blakely's innovative product, her persistence in the face of rejection, and her ability to connect with customers directly.
The Reality of Building a Brand
While stories like Spanx are inspiring, they're not the norm. According to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics:
- About 20% of new businesses fail during the first two years of operation.
- About 45% fail during the first five years.
- About 65% fail during the first 10 years.
However, those that succeed often have more control over their destiny and potentially higher profit margins than franchises.
Comparing the Paths: Real-World Considerations
1. Initial Investment and Ongoing Costs
- Franchising: According to a FranData study, the median initial investment for a franchise is $250,000, with ongoing royalty fees typically ranging from 4% to 6% of gross sales.
- Building a Brand: Costs vary widely, but a study by the Kauffman Foundation found that the average cost to start a business is about $30,000.
2. Time to Profitability
- Franchising: A study by Franchise Business Review found that 37% of food franchises are profitable within the first year, compared to only 8% of independent restaurants.
- Building a Brand: The same study found that only 22% of independent businesses across all industries were profitable in their first year.
These statistics show a significant difference in first-year profitability between franchises and independent businesses.
Food franchises, in particular, show a higher success rate, with 37% achieving profitability in the first year compared to just 22% of independent businesses across all industries.
This suggests that franchising, especially in the food sector, may offer a faster path to profitability than starting an independent business from scratch.
3. Creative Control and Flexibility
- Franchising: Extensive restrictions are standard. For example, McDonald's franchisees must adhere to strict guidelines on everything from menu items to store design, operational procedures, and even local marketing efforts. These constraints are typically more numerous and rigid than those faced by independent brands.
- Building a Brand: While not without limitations, independent brands generally enjoy significantly more creative freedom. For instance, Airbnb was able to completely redesign their app and website in 2016 to combat discrimination on their platform - a level of sweeping change that would be difficult or impossible in most franchise systems. However, independent brands still face some restrictions, such as industry regulations, trademark laws, and market expectations.
4. Support and Resources
There are numerous educational programs, resources, and support systems available for entrepreneurs looking to build their own brands.
1. Brand Building Resources:
- Government agencies: The Small Business Administration (SBA) offers extensive free counseling, training, and resources.
- Educational institutions: Many universities offer entrepreneurship programs and courses.
- Online platforms: Websites like Coursera, Udemy, and edX provide courses on branding, marketing, and business development.
- Industry associations: Offer networking, mentorship, and educational opportunities.
- Incubators and accelerators: Provide mentorship, funding, and intensive training programs.
- Books, podcasts, and blogs: Countless free and paid resources from successful entrepreneurs and experts.
2. Franchising Resources:
- Franchisor training: Often comprehensive but focused specifically on their system.
- Ongoing support: Varies by franchise, but typically includes operational and marketing assistance.
- Peer network: Other franchisees within the system.
While franchises do offer structured support, the ecosystem for independent brand builders is vast and diverse. Entrepreneurs have access to a wide array of flexible, customizable resources that can be tailored to their specific needs and industry.
Making Your Decision: Questions to Ask Yourself
1. How much capital do you have access to?
2. Are you comfortable following a set system, or do you prefer full creative control?
3. Do you have experience in your chosen industry?
4. How quickly do you need to see a return on your investment?
5. Are you prepared for the higher risk that comes with potentially higher rewards?
Remember, there's no one-size-fits-all answer. Your decision should align with your personal goals, financial situation, and risk tolerance.
Whether you choose to franchise or build your own brand, success ultimately comes down to hard work, smart decision-making, and a bit of luck.
Take the time to research thoroughly, speak with others who have taken each path, and consider seeking advice from a business mentor or consultant before making your decision.
The entrepreneurial journey is challenging but rewarding. Whichever path you choose, stay focused on providing value to your customers, and success will follow.
However, if you’re looking for a middle ground that combines the benefits of both options, Trend Hijacking might be the perfect solution.
Our solution allows you to start a business with a proven system while giving you the freedom to make it your own.
With its low startup costs, flexibility, and scalability, our program provides an ideal platform for anyone looking to build a successful business without the headaches of franchising or the challenges of starting from scratch—which include operational hassles and other tasks.
Ready to explore the possibilities? Visit Trend Hijacking and see how our program can help you create a thriving, managed-for-you business today.
